Cultural Constraints in Management by G. Hofstede - 904 Words

A Critical Review of Hofstede, G. 1993, Cultural Constraints in Management Theories, The Executive, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 81-94. There have been many research and studies on the national cultures and its consequences on management theories by numerous researchers. Of those many, ‘Cultural constraints on management theories,’ by Hofstede (1993) is one that has been talked about by most scholars. He strongly claimed that management is a function of culture and that culture influences the way managers behave. In explaining this relationship he used a model where differences in national cultures were categorised into five dimensions. One such practical application he did on the model was the comparison of the United States (US) culture with rest of the world to explain the exact relationship between culture and management. This paper will firstly give a synopsis of Hofstede (1980, 1993) article. Secondly, his work on five dimensional cultural framework model is critiqued. Specifically, this paper critiques that Hofstede; limited culture to only four dimensions; limited the sample size to only a one m ultinational corporation (IBM); methodically flawed the fifth dimension; and emphasised on only cultural differences and not commonalities. The paper concludes that though Hofstede made a good research and studies on the relationship between culture and management theories, there is still need for further research and development in this area to establish a constructive and reliableShow MoreRelatedAn Analysis of Management and Leadership Strategies Using the Hofstede Cultural Dimensions Model616 Words   |  3 PagesAnalysis of Management a Leadership Strategies Using the Hofstede Cultural Dimensions Model Introduction The Hofstede Cultural Dimensions Model is invaluable in evaluating the variations in cultural values across 93 different nations Dr. Hofstede profiled throughout his research efforts over the last three decades. Many corporations rely on this model for planning their globalization strategies, specifically looking at how best to align managers and leaders with specific attributes to nationsRead MoreCross-Cultural Perspectives: Evaluating the Ethical and Social Responsibility of Software Outsourcing at Oracle1116 Words   |  4 Pagescompanies whose role is critical to national defense, is an area not as well defined as it potentially could be from an ethics perspective (Pratt, 2008). Exacerbating this ethical issue is the one of cultural variations being so significant with India compared to the U.S. and the costs associated ensuring cultural congruency (Miller, Anderson, 2004). In the vast differences of cultures there is ample opportunity for ethical lapses and for confidential dat a to be compromised (Rucker, 2003). Oracle CorporationRead MoreRole of Human Resource Management in Global Organizations Strategies612 Words   |  2 PagesIntroduction Human Resource Management (HRM) is an integral element of any global organisations international business strategy as globalization is accelerating cultures together faster than ever as the product lifecycles in industries continue to accelerate. In addition to the quickening pace of innovation globally, the accuracy required in terms of knowledge management to ensure these initiatives keep pace with globally-based timelines is more critical than ever. While accuracy, acuity of informationRead MorePersuasive Approach to Communication681 Words   |  3 Pagesbetween China, the United Kingdome and India. The cultural biases and frames of reference will vary significantly across each of these cultures, making humor difficult to apply equally across each (Hofstede, 1993). Using the Hofstede Model of cultural dimensions, insights can be gained into each of the countries as this framework takes into account five different dimensions to explain variation in national cultures (Hofstede, McC rae, 2004). Dr. Geert Hofstede has provided the model online so country culturesRead MoreCross Cultural Approaches to Professional Leadership815 Words   |  3 PagesCross Cultural Approaches to Professional Leadership Authors name Authors institutional affiliation Authors note Cross Cultural Approaches to Professional Leadership If I were the CEO of a multinational corporation in the 21st century, it would be critical for me to develop and employ a cross cultural approach to the leadership in consultation with Hofstedes Five Cultural Dimensions. Though I have prior knowledge of management theories and other examples of Hofstedes work, Cultural ConstraintsRead MoreA List of Ten International Human Resource Mistakes Made by Mr. Fisher: Intercultural Communication Case Study719 Words   |  3 Pagesstudys timeframe. Seventh, Mr., Fisher neglected to consider how the cultural differences between the Untied States, Belgium and Germany would influence the hiring decision. Using the Hofstede Model of Cultural Dimensions Mr. Fisher could have seen how vastly different the U.S. culture is from these two other nations, and realized quickly that bringing an America into these nations would lead to cultural shock at the least (Hofstede, McCrae, 2004). Eight, there is no mention of an initial Joint VentureRead MoreValue s Across Cultures2688 Words   |  11 Pagesinfluences the selection from available modes, means, and ends of action†. According to Husted (1999, pp. 339-359) â€Å"cultural values are those conceptions of the desirable that are characteristic of a particular people†. Wines and Napier (1992) states that value influence dominant cultural practices. Thus it is seen that every country / nation has their own value system and cultural practices. In order to see different values across cultures two different countries are selected (that are U.S.A andRead MoreGlobalization of Knowledge Management1837 Words   |  7 Pagesï » ¿Globalization of Knowledge Management: Evaluating Best Practices and Defining Strategies For Optimal Performance Executive Summary Knowledge is the accelerator and catalyst of global competitive strength in any industry today, from the most manufacturing-intensive to the service-driven. Combining the virtualization aspects of work teams and the accelerating aspects of knowledge management is creating major disruptions in industries globally today (Stevens, Karkkainen, Lampela,  2009). The abilityRead MoreKaren Leary Case1807 Words   |  8 PagesSummary The case of Karen Leary illustrates the implications cultural conflict can have on business organizations and office culture. A common mistake managers make is undermining the power of cultural constraints at the organizational level. After six years as a financial consultant at Merrill Lynch, Karen Leary was promoted to general manager at the Elmville branch in Chicago. Leary wanted to achieve success at the branch office by building high-producing, successful group of professionals whoRead Moreâ€Å"with Increasing Globalization, Organizational Culture Will Be More Important Than National Culture†. Discuss and Critically Evaluate This Statement.2797 Words   |  12 Pagesstatement. As our world becomes increasingly globalized, a term used by marketing guru Theodore Levitt to depict extensive developments and advancements in communications and technology, resulting in an emerging worldwide cultural homogeneity (N. Asgary and A. Walle, 2002, The Cultural Impact of Globalization: Economic Activity and Social). With the diversification of our workforce, in terms of culture, gender and ethnicity, the argument of whether organizational culture is more crucial than national